Najib Razak / Tun Dr Mahathir / Umno & Barisan Nasional

The Prime Minister is misleading the people with his FAQ

The Prime Minister issued his latest FAQ which yet again did not answer any of the questions posed to him.

We would have thought that he could at least explain what exactly the cash/paper assets/units fiasco all about since he is also the Finance Minister and the Advisor of 1MDB. But he did not.

In fact, when it is concerning 1MDB, the PM (or maybe his coterie of failed consultants) are desperately spinning the issue further.

He said:

Indeed, some of the allegations that have been made have no grounding in reality, for instance Tun’s claim that I am responsible for a loss of RM42 billon on 1MDB’s balance sheet. This appears to be a deliberate twisting of the facts as 1MDB has not made a loss of this amount. This is the amount of its total debt; debt that is far exceeded by the company’s assets of RM51 billion, as audited and confirmed by Deloitte. Most large companies around the world have high levels of debt, there is nothing unusual about this.

In the first place, Tun never claimed that there was a RM42 billion loss in 1MDB. He said, and every rational people in Malaysia agreed that the RM42 billion loans 1MDB took are unaccounted for and some may have been lost. Disappeared. Vanished.

Surely the Prime Minister must not think that Tun and the rest of fellow Malaysians are too stupid to discern between the words ‘loss’, and ‘unaccounted money lost’?

In Bahasa Malaysia, lost is ‘hilang’, ‘lesap‘. While the word loss means ‘rugi’.

Q: Where is the RM27 billion? A: Sultan Pahang supports me

Q: Where is the RM27 billion?
A: Sultan Pahang supports me

If the Prime Minister’s so called corporate comms team could not grasp this most basic of definition, then no wonder the Prime Minister has an image of a clueless leader.

The fact that the Prime Minister is deliberately trying to mislead the people in his own FAQ while accusing Tun as twisting the facts is so ironic, we just had to smile at this sheer foolishness.

Nobody ever said that 1MDB is suffering a P&L loss of RM42 billion. People were asking, if the assets bought was RM15 billion at cost, while the loans taken was RM42 billion, then where is the balance of RM27 billion?

It does not matter if 1MDB has assets worth RM52 billion. The truth is in the pudding. If 1MDB is having a really strong balance sheet, then why the need to borrow from MOF, nearly RM1 billion in standby credit last March and RM2 billion from a billionaire last February just to pay off its loan interests?

What happened to the often repeated mantra – ‘there is nothing wrong with 1MDB, they have billions of cash and a lot of assets’?

He further added:

He (Tun) also claimed that I do not answer issues surrounding 1MDB, but I have gone beyond thatand instructed the Auditor General to conduct an audit of 1MDB, the results of which will be presented to the bipartisan Public Accounts Committee. This should ensure that the process is transparent, and all questions that have been asked of the company are independently answered by legitimate bodies rather than politically motivated sources.

Enough with the AG report already please. Going beyond answering, but veering the topic by saying you have instructed the AG to audit 1MDB is still not answering the questions!

Why are we, the questioning people, being treated like an idiot by this Prime Minister?

Simple questions like, ‘who is Jho Low?”, or why did 1MDB enter into a JV agreement with Petro Saudi and its contracts signed just within 3 days without any due diligence done before accepting the dubious ‘oil exploration rights’ in exchange for USD1.5 billion in equity?

The Auditor General could never answer these two questions let alone other tougher questions. Yet, the PM is asking people to wait for the report. What can it prove? Just like 1MDB’s external auditor, the AG report might prove nothing. There are so many unscrupulous companies that had obtained good, unqualified audit reports from external auditors throughout history.

And who are these legitimate bodies independently answering questions about 1MDB? Please don’t tell us, it is all those dubious Facebook accounts set up just to defend it? What credibility do they have? Are they the staff of 1MDB? Are they getting paid by the Prime Minister?

1MDB should be answering the questions themselves, on daily basis. This is crisis management 101. But the Prime Minister himself is telling the people that external bodies are answering on behalf of 1MDB. How incompetent!

There is also evidence that the Prime Minister has no clue to what the role of external auditors is all about when on May 18th, he stated:

“Auditors will not sign if even RM1 million is missing. Now it is said that RM42 billion has vanished. How can it vanish? It hasn’t vanished, there are assets, there are liabilities.”

The auditing community had a good laugh when the PM said that. In reality, when auditing  billion ringgit company like 1MDB, the auditors will not even check something relatively miniscule as RM1 million.

Auditors use sampling method, and materiality testing. There is no way auditors can audit anything 100%. Their audit opinion and report even stated that.

And on top of it all, obviously the RM42 billion loans can be seen in 1MDB’s accounts. It is there for all to see in the balance sheet. It’s called historical accounting. But the money is vanished, obviously used up by unknown people (unknown at this point of time). How can we make ourselves clearer to this clueless PM?

This what happens when we have a career politician as a leader, and non-financial people as speech writers. To digress, a career politician is a person who never gained any meaningful experience in other sectors than politics.

It is sad to see how an embattled Prime Minister is desperately trying to hoodwink the people into supporting him. Worse, his efforts to defend himself fall flat on his face due to the incompetent advisors surrounding him.

Perhaps the Prime Minister need to apply the bullshit indicator onto himself first before giving out further FAQs.

9 thoughts on “The Prime Minister is misleading the people with his FAQ

  1. I read the “answers” and good grief, this PM really is stupid beyond words. He is worse than the previous one. Three tries, and he still misses the mark. Goddem, how is that even possible. What was he doing all those years studying in the UK, disco dancing? If so, he sucks even at that.

    Like

  2. Quote: “Why are we, the questioning people, being treated like an idiot by this Prime Minister?”

    Er hemm … perhaps he is one himself. Just wondering.

    Like

  3. Those answers could have been written by his subordinates. No way of telling.

    To convince the public, Najib has 2 options:
    1 Sue Tun Dr M for slander, which won’t be the first time for Najib as he had sued others before.
    2 Agree to a live debate with the Statesman.

    Then the public can deduce who is the sharper politician.

    Like

  4. Does the current Prime Minister has any Grey Matter upstairs?…He will not pass any secondary school exam much less respond to a 90 year old man simple questions.

    Like

  5. Can I take a stab at guessing where the RM27 billion went? Whoever supports this dimwit especially in UMNO, have their hands in the cookie jar. Hence the SILENCE. And the LOUD SUPPORT for dimwit. Naughty, naughty. This is getting ridiculous. I want blood. No more just resign and get lost. I want this dimwit to be held responsible and if found guilty, jailed. Seriously I couldn’t give a flying f*ck to give this dimwit face just because his father was the great Bapa Pembangunan. Dimwit is smearing mud on his father’s name. And please don’t give him Tun-ship till he explains where exactly the bloody RM27 billion went. And who is Jho Low in all this shit.

    Like

  6. Guys, u need some understanding in accounting to actually comment on loss, profits, balance sheets etc. On paper, everything can be accounted for, but you have to verify the legitimacy of the accounts. Therefore you need an understanding in auditing practices as well. Since it s really a 3-4 yr bachelor s degree program, I cannot simply explain here. Haha! But simply put, a balance sheet must balance. Tunggu lah tengok financial statements dia n result of audit tu. Sabar je lah. Be objective. Make a judgement based on facts, not emotion. I m a BN supporter but not Najib s supporter, though, in case u think i m defending him….

    Like

    • I am an engineer…I could easily manipulate my engineering design and calculation to make it appears as if my design achieve its required performance (on paper). Lay person will not understand and wont be able to pick this up however other “good” engineer should be able to identify this deliberate manipulation.

      I would like to think that it is the same with accounting….On paper, everything can be accounted for or be made as if everything has been accounted for and balance.

      However I would not stop non engineers to question engineering design or calculation. Some criteria would be common sense which others can legitimately identify and question. Whether the question is credible or “silly” coming from whoever it is… as an engineer and doing a sound engineering design… I can easily ANSWER and response adequately all those questions.

      Now the weird thing is…..why havent those relevant 1MDB “accountant” answer all those questions with regard to the accounting of 1MDB….There is something really wrong here….Why is the silence?

      They said that the “big four” accounting firm are reputable due to their international reputation…I say that this is b*ll sh*t!

      I myself have work with the biggest international engineering firm overseas where others has considered as “reputable” engineering firm, I can testify to the many errors that they have done over the years.

      I am quite sure that the same applies to these “big four”. In fact over the years they have already been implicated with many dubious auditing scandal example the Tyco Int Scandal (Pricewaterhouse cooper), the Lehman Brothers (Ernst and Young), the Merill Lynch Scandal (Delloitte)….many more!

      Like

Astound us with your intelligence!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s