Politics in general

Malaysia promotes itself internationally. Is there a problem?

Yes, according to Malaysiakini, this is a problem that should be highlighted:

International broadcaster BBC has admitted that it has aired to millions of people worldwide, programmes made by a public relations company hired by the Malaysian government.

According to Nik Nazmi, this is also a problem:

Putrajaya and Kuching were found to have paid FBC hundreds of millions of ringgit for strategic communications services and the production of friendly content for their governments, something clearly in contravention of fundamental media laws and ethics. It must also be pointed out that FBC was also involved in the engaging of APCO Worldwide to lobby the US government on behalf of Barisan Nasional to promote Malaysia’s pro-business and pro-reform credentials as well as the reforms and anti-terrorism policies introduced…

Surely Putrajaya and Kuching must now disclose their role in and extent of this illegal public relations campaign. This scandal ironically comes in the wake of the censoring of the Economist magazine report on the Bersih 2.0 debacle. As a result, Prime Minister Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak was forced to concede the need to review national censorship policies. We would now like the Prime Minister to come clean on the FBC fiasco to explain how hundreds of millions of ringgit of taxpayers’ money were being funnelled not towards the national image, but for the interests of his party.

Both Malaysiakini and Nik Nazmi (the Communications Director of PKR) must be grasping at straws to even bring this issue up.

Nik Nazmi and Malaysiakini must also confused itself that Barisan Nasional is not part of the government. Nik Nazmi even become more foolish when he, as a member of parliament seems to think that he is not part of the government of Malaysia.

Here is the original article by BBC regarding this matter:

BBC drops film-maker over Malaysia impartiality fears

The BBC is investigating how it aired programmes made by a company that allegedly received millions of pounds in payments from Malaysia’s government.

The BBC has suspended all programming by UK-based production company FBC, which has made documentaries on controversial issues in Malaysia.

The BBC said it has strict agreements with independent producers “including avoiding any conflict of interest”.

FBC has denied any wrongdoing in its programme-making for any broadcaster.

FBC told the UK newspaper The Independent via its lawyers that “at no time have the television programmes made for the BBC ever been influenced or affected by our client’s commercial activities“.

‘Strict agreements’

FBC has made several documentaries for the BBC about Malaysia since 2009, examining controversial issues such as the palm oil industry and its treatment of indigenous people.

The most recent programme was aired on BBC World News this summer.

A BBC spokesman said: “FBC has admitted to the BBC that it has worked for the Malaysian government. That information was not disclosed to the BBC as we believe it should have been when the BBC contracted programming from FBC.

“Given this, the BBC has decided to transmit no more programming from FBC while it reviews its relationship with the company.”

“All independent TV companies who produce programmes for BBC World News have to sign strict agreements to ensure programmes meet the BBC’s editorial guidelines, including avoiding any conflict of interest.”

The more indepth story can be read in this article by The Independent.

From the BBC article above, the gist of the story is that BBC somehow is perplexed that a production company received money by the Malaysian government to produce programs that may breach their strict editorial guidelines. There are investigating the situation right now. In the mean time, the said production company, FBC Media, denied any wrong doing i.e., breaching the agreement.

I do not know how they do it in the West, but for the benefit of Malaysiakini and Nik Nazmi, whenever we employ a production company to create a content programmes, we have to pay for the services rendered.

This services is worth approximately RM28million ringgit.

Excerpt from Supplementary Budget 2009

Since this amount was tabled in Parliament we can now promptly tell Nik Nazmi that his assertions that this exercise tantamount to ‘illegal public relations campaign’ is wrong.

And what is so wrong about “promoting Malaysia’s pro-business and pro-reform credentials as well as the reforms and anti-terrorism policies introduced”?

Attracting foreign investments to Malaysia is frowned upon by Opposition?

BBC and CNN believe production company must work for free when producing programs for Malaysia?

So this issue of promoting Malaysia to the eyes of the world has become a tremendously evil thing a government of Malaysia would do?

We do not have to delve deeper into our brain compartments to know that the benefits of promoting Malaysia worldwide outweighs the costs associated with it.

One of the documentary produced by FBC Media was about our palm oil industry. Citing the ‘key role of the Malaysian palm oil industry in meeting the growing demand for food in countries such as China and India. “Once an efficient production centre for rubber, Malaysia over the years has increasingly turned to oil palm,” said the voiceover. “The country is now one of the world’s biggest exporters, producing 40 per cent of global supply, and is reaping the economic benefits of higher demand from Asia.”‘ Source.

Another documentary is about the indigenous people in Sarawak, specifically the Ibans where it ‘explored the lifestyle of the tribal Iban people and took a boat ride to visit a traditional longhouse. “Tourism not only brings in money, it also encourages youngsters to keep alive skills that might otherwise have died out,” he reported. “For the past 40 years, the Malaysian government has practised an affirmative-action policy aimed at raising the living standards of indigenous groups.”‘ (same source)

Pardon me, maybe I am naive. But I would always support any moves to promote and advertise our country’s oil palm and tourism internationally. Is it a sense of misplaced patriotism? Maybe. But people like Nik Nazmi and Malaysiakini who not only displayed utter disregard of the truth and simply criticize without substance, worse, in contempt of what the government is doing for the sake of Malaysians, be surely the least patriotic people at this moment.

On a side note, the Government of Malaysia is made of three branches – the Executive, the Legislative and the Judiciary.

The opposition in Malaysia is part of the Legislative branch by default because of their position as Members of Parliament. Therefore whatever they do in Parliament is reflective of the actions made by the Government of Malaysia.

Nik Nazmi must realize that once in a while, he must work for the benefit of the people in Malaysia since he as the tiny part of the Government, must work for the people. If other countries can lobby and pay money to promote their policies and causes, then surely Malaysia can do the same.

Are we that naive to think that BBC or CNN or other international cable news never receive any money from interested parties to air their propaganda?

So again, what is the problem here?

Thank you.

15 thoughts on “Malaysia promotes itself internationally. Is there a problem?

  1. JMD, org macam Nik Nazmi (same dgn geng2 PR yg lain), tak sepatutnya jadi pembangkang apatah lagi jadi MP di Parlimen. takde standard. research n homework takde isi, yg dia tau apa2 pun kena spin n twist untuk jadi issue hentam kerajaan. nak cakap bodoh, sekolah bukan main tinggi lagi. ntahla, saya minta sgt kat PR letakla calon2 yg elok sikit bila PRU nanti. buat malu Malaysia je ada pembangkang serupa budak kecik menangis tak dapat aiskrim. lebih elok lagi kalau PR tak bertanding langsung.

    Like

  2. “Astound us with your intelligence!”

    Lu biar serious…discriminative beb…

    On behalf of mamatminah bingais gua nak komplen sket …

    anyway….what is the difference between a Tourism promotion ad that shows clean white sandy beaches when the actual beach is kotor giler babeng…..

    TV Stations still take on advertising money for lousy crappy product tak sedap langsung…

    As for BBC World News….conflict of interest situation….I bet that happens everyday….

    such a cliché …..kecoh lebih la beb

    Like

  3. Dear JMD,

    TMI carried the report extensively. I checked at the time but no western MSM except ABC, other than BBC/CNN if I remember correctly, carried the story. Meaning – no issue. Gua pun malas lah.

    “One of the documentary produced by FBC Media was about our palm oil industry. Citing the ‘key role of the Malaysian palm oil industry in meeting the growing demand for food in countries such as China and India.”

    Read together with Another Brick in The Wall, “Why is George Soros selling gold and buying farmland? ” http://anotherbrickinwall.blogspot.com/2011/08/why-is-george-soros-selling-gold-and.html how significant is that?

    Your post especially disclosure in parliament is a clincher.

    Another good one.

    Regards
    Freddie

    Like

  4. Aku dulu ikut gak baca mamat budu tu punya blog. Sangat idealis. Ntah sekrang dah jadi politician bawan Anwar. Geli geliman aku.

    Kalau lah semuanya terbalik, PR memerintah, Malaysiakini is the new Utusan. Senang citer.

    Like

  5. So far there doesn’t seem to be any conflict – palm oils and indigenous people. There could be future conflicts, but I don’t see why such things aren’t dealt with in a case-by-case basis.

    To those who complain about the price of the services, I don’t think you can run a country if you have a kedekut piang mentality. Or if you are afraid of big numbers.

    adam

    Like

  6. Jebat

    Thank God for websites like this. The blogs are full of Pakatan rabid haters confusing the forests for the trees on one side, and no-class UMNO punters spewing completely inconsequential nonsense on the other. Pening kepala aku nak baca. Please keep it up bro.

    Like

  7. Kerja dia orang memburuk burukkan negara saja. Pergi Indonesia buat hal (macam laporan TEMPO tu!), pergi Filipna pun buat hal. Mana mana saja dia orang pergi ceritakan yang negara buruk, tak ada satu pun yang baik.

    Nampaknya chimpanzee ni nak kita bayar orang memburukkan negara lah, bukan macam tu kah? Malaysiakini pun dapat dana untuk memburukkan negara. Apa nak hairan sangat dengan sikap dia orang ni? Kalau mereka berkuasa barulah semua baik, lebih lebih lagi kalau anugerah tuhan tu jadi PM – semua masalah akan diselesaikan dan Malaysia akan menjadi baik dengan sekelip mata saja.

    Tell them to go fly kites lah!

    Like

    • More than telling them to fly kites, we should tell those who do not respect and live by the Constitution of this country fully that they should look for countries whose Constitution they can respect and live by.

      Many of those who denigrate this country resent the sensitive clauses of the Constitution and talk about lack of democracy and what not. And those foreign blokes gulped down Anwarista arguments hook, line and sinker. Without checking the facts in this country. How can implementing or promoting the sensitive clauses – that are protected by the Sedition Act, anyway – be undemocratic when those were approved by Parliament twice – once at Merdeka, another at the formation of Malaysia.

      And, bloody hell, that so-called democracy-promoting, Jewish-infested, Washington-based organisation giving money to Malaysiakini and Bersih support the anti-ISA calls not even realizing that their own country, USA, practices detention without trial in Guantanamo Bay. They have about 200 detainees at the last count.

      And these buggers criticize Malaysia’s efforts at promoting the image of the country abroad. Damn them.

      Like

  8. “hello JMD, lu ada pakai otak ka? depa ni opposition, dah tentulah oppose semua benda yang kerajaan BN buat. semua tu masuk dalam kroni BN.” <— jawapan biasa yang kita dengar. apa nak buat, since almost sape-sape pun leh jadik MP…

    Like

Astound us with your intelligence!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s